It was supposed to be just another step toward tightening their grip on the division, however, instead, the Dodgers walked off the field with a loss that looked heavier than the scorecard showed. Costly errors in the outfield did not just gift opportunities to the Rockies—the issues flipped momentum in a game the Dodgers had every scope to win. That unraveling spotlighted Teoscar Hernández, whose issues in right field became the turning point that no one in the team could ignore.
Adding fuel to the fire, frustration boiled over once the final out was recorded. Reports quickly revealed that Mookie Betts, Dave Roberts and Andrew Friedman huddled together in a closed-door meeting, sparking quick speculation. “Mookie Betts, Dave Roberts and Andrew Friedman have a closed-door meeting after the Dodgers’ loss, which featured misplays in right by Teoscar. Intriguing,” posted by Houston Mitchell of the Los Angeles Times. Fans did not need long to put two and two together—the analysis had to be related to accountability and what comes next.
The heart of the issue lies in Teoscar Hernández’s defense. The star’s offensive production has been powerful—second on the team with 74 RBIs and tied for second with 20 home runs—however, the star’s glove has let the Dodgers down in vital moments. Monday’s loss was no distinctive. A bad read in the third inning and a dropped ball in the ninth were the kinds of mistakes that transformed the game’s outcome. As Dave Roberts bluntly said, “We should have won that game. This is a hard one.” For the manager, typically measured by his statement, that frustration spoke volumes.
Naturally, fans and analysts alike began to float outcomes. One of the most talked-about options? Sliding Mookie Betts back into right field, where the star has proven himself with six Gold Gloves in seven seasons. The move would shore up the defense while opening up scopes for Miguel Rojas and Alex Freeland—the 2 stars, more than capable shortstops—to take over in the infield. The manager didn’t dismiss the thought either, saying, “Defense is a big part of postseason baseball and winning baseball. He’s just got to continue to get better.” Still, it raised an intricate balancing act: can the Dodgers afford Hernández’s bat, however, sacrifice his glove?
That concern lingers like an unshaken echo. The Dodgers know the offense needs Hernández, however, the postseason is not forgiving when defense falters. As the manager put it after Yamamoto’s gem was wasted: “We get a starter that goes seven innings, their starter goes four innings and we don’t win this game. That’s a hard one to put into words.” Between the fans’ enhancing impatience and the internal urgency behind those closed doors, one thing is clear—the team’s margin for error is shrinking and the calls for transformation are only growing louder.
Fans react to Dodgers lineup dilemma
The first wave of reactions zeroed in on what some see as an obvious outcome. One fan bluntly said: “Mookie to Right, Teo to Left, Conforto to Waivers. It should have been like this since April. Enough is enough.” The message could not be clearer: defensive stability in right field begins with Mookie Betts. Given Teoscar Hernández’s costly miscues and Michael Conforto’s underwhelming production, the need for a shuffle is not just mental—it is backed by performance trends that scream for change.
Another hot topic? Why Mookie Betts has not been locked into his best position all along. “So wtf is Mookie playing shortstop? He’s a 6-time Gold Glove winner in right field,” another fan said. The data tell the story—Betts’ defensive brilliance is undeniable. Across his career, the star has established himself as a premier outfielder of MLB, winning six Gold Gloves in seven seasons before being shifted to the infield experiment.
The frustration carried a pleading tone from others: “Please go back to right, Mookie.” With good reason. In 2025, the star’s logged innings in shortstop and right field, however, Betts’ track record in the outfield is unmatched. Betts’ Gold Glove pedigree and his versatility to also cover second base speak volumes, however, at the end of the day, fans think his greatest value to the team’s championship push comes in right field.
That said, not every reaction was critical. Some fans were quick to defend the star, reminding others of Betts’ selflessness: “Mookie is a team player who will sacrifice himself to help make the team better.” It is true—he has proven that time and again. Whether it is moving to shortstop, shifting in the batting order to accommodate Shohei Ohtani and filling gaps when injuries struck, Betts has consistently prioritized the team’s needs over his comfort. That willingness to adapt has been a blessing and a curse—helping the team to maintain flexibility but also leaving questions related to whether Betts’ talent is being maximized.
Of course, not every fan was hopeful. Some vented outright anger at Roberts’ stubbornness: “Nothing will change. Roberts keeps trotting out his same dumbass lineup, thinking Conforto is good and Teo has a Gold Glove.” It is a sentiment that highlights the enhancing impatience in the team. For some, the issue is not just Hernández and Conforto—it is the manager’s insistence on sticking to a formula that clearly is not working. With the postseason coming quickly, that frustration could boil over if adjustments aren’t made quickly.
Fans have spoken and their message is loud: fix the defense, put Mookie back where he belongs and stop wasting scopes. Whether the Dodgers listen remains to be seen, however, with October coming quickly, the margin for error is razor-thin.
Fuente: https://www.essentiallysports.com/mlb-baseball-news-enough-is-enough-los-angeles-demands-big-change-as-mookie-betts-joins-closed-door-meeting-after-teoscar-hernandezs-rough-night/
